book writing,  Music

First Novel vs Second Album Syndrome

I have a bit of a theory about why people talk about first novel, but second album, syndrome. As I’m no longer an academic, I can just have a theory and don’t need to back it up with evidence or citations, so here goes.

First novel syndrome is usually characterised by over-writing, too much plot and infodumping. It stems from an author trying too hard. The eagerness to demonstrate “I am a writer, look!” I say this as someone’s whose first novel has some of these elements (it’s still brilliant and you should buy it, of course). Now that I’m halfway through my fourth novel I can see all those aspects in hindsight. The main difference was that I stopped trying so hard to be someone else’s version of a good writer and settled more confidently into just writing. This doesn’t mean I stopped trying hard, but I stopped being a try-hard.

Second album syndrome by contrast is when an artist has had a successful first album with a well defined sound, and then struggles with the follow-up (yes, we’re looking at you Stone Roses). This can arise for a variety of reasons: The artist may have had only one really good album in them; they are touring so don’t have time to compose the way they did before; they try to replicate the first album too much; they attempt to go in a different direction. It can be seen as the opposite of the first novel problem, in that the artist starts out comfortable and then tries too hard to do something different, to demonstrate that they are more than a one album wonder.

I reckon this difference arises through a combination of factors. Often music artists are relatively young when they release their first album. They have probably been gigging for a few years, developing the songs before anyone really paid them attention. They’ve developed that sound based on their own instincts. Then they get attention and a new factor to consider enters the room. For writers the opposite is often the case. They may be a bit older, they’ve been working and reworking their novel through writing groups, critical readers, scouting for agents. Then their novel comes out, and it may get some success, but often not. With that out of the way, they can get on with writing more naturally.

Of course, there are plenty of writers who have massive debut novels, and musicians whose second album is better than their first. It’s not a universal law, Chad. But there may be something in the nature of the two art forms and media that shapes it. That’s my excuse anyway.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php