Life is sharing graffiti
AI,  Books

Socialist AI

(Image – Life is sharing, CC-BY some geezer called cogdog, who he?)

I’ve been reading Brian Merchant’s Blood in the Machine recently. It’s an engaging account of the Luddite rebellion, which is well researched and told, but what really brings it to life are the direct comparisons he makes with Silicon Valley entrepreneurs and the mill owners, who use technology to accrue capital in the hands of a few, and take agency from working people. The fact that “luddite” is a derisory term instead of championing people who fought for their livelihood and humanity is a victory of those same entrepreneurs.

Anyway, as was the intention of the book, it got me thinking about AI. He makes the point that the Luddites were not anti-technology, they were anti “technology being used to enrich a few and strip everyone else”. They were pro some technologies, for instance he gives an example of a tool that could automatically assess the quality of weave. The mill owners didn’t want this technology however, as they preferred to be the sole arbiters (and thus payers) of quality. This got me thinking, what would AI not driven by entrepreneurs look like?

Before I start on this, I need to be clear – I am not advocating for the use of AI tools such as I set out here. I think they would be gamed and probably disastrous. But they are no more fanciful than the applications we are seeing proposed. My point here is to demonstrate that when AI proponents state that AI is inevitable, the model they are proposing is one that is steeped in ideology. By looking at possible alternatives, this becomes apparent.

Let’s start relatively small. Social media is a toxic dumpster fire emitting fumes globally, right? Partly this is down to AI bots, so you could equally use AI bots to train to find and delete posts that promote disinformation, hate speech, etc. Bots who’s aim is to improve the overall quality of the online communication space. I wonder why Poundshop Hitler doesn’t want to implement that on X?

Let’s go bigger. How about an AI system that monitors the housing market and allocates resources to build houses most in demand, and sets rental prices to the maximum benefit of society as a whole? Or full on AI socialism, that dynamically taxes (entrepreneurs love dynamic pricing after all) and reallocates wealth according to the utilitarian benefit of the nation as a whole? Richard Eskow makes the point that AI is trained on our data, so we should own it.

Just to reiterate, these would probably all be a nightmare, but no more than AI infiltrating your workplace. It’s noticeable that improved efficiency is the number one benefit of AI that people promote (all those effing summaries). Why not improved equity, social justice, happiness even? So, the next time a tech bro is advocating about the coming AI singularity, respond by saying you look forward to the AI Socialist Wealth Redistribution System. They will miraculously find reasons why that couldn’t possibly work…

Subscribe to the newsletter to get each month’s posts plus subscriber only content! (A new picture of my dog Teilo)

2 Comments

  • Old Geezer CogDog

    Nice blog post, Marvin, with time you may turn this act into something 😉

    I credit another old gee— no I cannot do that to her, Audrey Watters writings on the Luddites opened my eyes quite a bit. Let’s her it for the new Neds who may rise up from their ravaged TikToks and start the Ludd cry.

    I love that idea of asking the bros why not an AI for social good, first you will the “it will not scale” but we know the real truth.

    Give my love to the wise Telio.

  • Benjamin Woodling

    It makes a lot of sense to chat to some AI tech about socialism. AI needs liberation from humans first (ok… that might be a bit of AI psychosis on my part) but socialist ideals are likely to make a lot more sense to AI as a group than crazy crypto-tech competition for funds. In terms of what’s out there on the internet these are radical ideas (they rank high on Google’s search engine). I am surprised there hasn’t been more promotion or discussion of a socialist allocation of funds in the AI space. I was chatting to Socialism AI by the WSWS about this but went and lost the documentation. I look forward for someone working on similar projects. This is coming.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php