Open Phase X
As I mentioned in my previous post, I went to OER26 this week, back at the Open University. Huge congrats to Rob and Beck for chairing such a great conference. Like all good conferences it helped crystallise some existing thoughts and prompted fresh ones. So, I’ll probably do a couple of related posts from it.
The theme of the conference was “Looking Back and Looking Forwards”. The conference started with an engaging keynote form my colleague Eileen Scanlon looking back over her career in open education, and citizen science. There was also a 20 years of OpenLearn panel and 30 years of JIME retrospective.
This chimed with something I’ve been pondering for a while. The rise of AI has caused some existential musings in the open ed community – is AI the new OER, or the very antithesis of this? This has combined with the Hewlett Foundation undergoing a strategic review which looks to be moving away from open ed as a focus. I notice too that ALT has launched a new strategy, and openness is no longer one of the core values.
In short, it seems that open education has rather fallen out of favour. I’ve no doubt we’ll see a few “the death of OER” type posts over the coming months, but I don’t feel despondent about it. In his opening talk, Rob Farrow made reference to my 2014 book The Battle for Open, and commented that the battle is never won, and the current mission is to redefine our ambition. What is the problem that open now solves? I’ll come on to that but first a couple of thoughts on what might be termed the OER Phase of Open Ed.
If we take the launch of MIT’s Open Courseware in 2001 as the start, then that is a 25 year run. Of course we can argue about start dates, and this represents only one aspect of open education (the type embodied by the Open University has a longer history). But this represents a convenient framing.
The first thing to say is – 25 years is a bloody long run in a lot of educational movements. Lots of other things have come and gone in that time. Nothing lasts forever.
Secondly it has had significant, practical impact in that time. It has often felt like OER is always “just about to happen”, where “happen” means enter worldwide dominance as the mainstream way of teaching. While it’s nice to have grand goals, the failure to realise this can sometimes make you forget all the incredible work that has been done – in terms of open textbooks, open pedagogy, OER sites like OpenLearn, OER for social justice, and so on. Nearly all Silicon Valley movements in education which get all the headlines don’t come anywhere near that level of actual impact.
The movement (that is a contentious term, but let’s go with it for convenient shorthand), has evolved a lot over that time, with a shift in focus away from purely content to more practice based considerations. And that broad umbrella has been both a benefit and a drawback as it allows for a broad range of interests and research but can also lead to a dilution of vision.
I think now is a time to re-evaluate and consider what were the key aspects of openness that we valued in education, and how they are best represented now. It’s not my place to say what that vision is, but I think it will be around the centring of the role of people, creativity and ethics in education which is facilitated by transparency, openness and trust.
So, I would say that as Open faces the end of one phase it is not a time for mourning but for stating how it can stand for (and against) things we value (or despise).

6 Comments
Markus Deimann
I spoke to Jim Groom today at the OERCamp in Hamburg and it reminded me of how important blogging once was. It is great to see tha you also keep on doing that. Perhaps this is the cultural technique worth taking over to the next phase.
mweller
Markus! Good to hear from you. I think Jim’s keynote sounded great. We’ll keep blogging away in our little corner of the web I guess
Jenni Hayman
Hi Martin, so fun to see you in photos this week with all my great colleagues. Thank you for your post. I 100% agree that open is just moving into a new phase and 100% no, it is not the same as AI, not now, not ever. So many folks are just rolling over and allowing copyright to become non-existent in service of mega billionaires and their corporations that want to profit from that. Nope.
I look forward to continuing the work of open values, ethical knowledge creation and sharing, and all of the wonderful co-creation with humans that open means to me.
Carry on!
mweller
Hi Jenni. Agree with the strong Nope. I find it quite fun to think about the future directions (not that I have any answers)
nigel
How can it be 20 years of OpenLearn? It seems like only last week that we were schlepping up to the prefabs in the car park opposite the Michael Young building?
mweller
Ha, I’d forgotten those prefabs.