AI,  metaphor

Tales from the riverbank

I was invited to give an online keynote to the Pedaforum conference in Finland last week. Their theme was sustainability of practice, so I decided to lean into that idea of sustainability and draw on metaphors from ecology. This came with my usual caveat of metaphors being drawn from nature being potentially dangerous. I used three – resilience, invasive species and rewilding. The main point I wanted to make however was not the metaphors themselves (which were of course, mindblowing) but rather that as educators we need conceptual tools to make our practice sustainable.

The first question to ask in terms of sustainability of practice, is sustainability of what? The things each of us might want to protect and grow might be very different. The second is to consider how you can approach that issue. You can rely on institutional or Governmental guidelines. But these are limited I feel. To take the obvious example of dealing with AI, this study of AI policies across UK higher ed institutions found that there was no shared approach and despite claims to put students first, most policies were about compliance and monitoring. The author, Sam Illingworth comments that:

“Universities are supposed to develop critical thinkers. If an institution’s own AI policy cannot model critical thinking about AI, if it resorts to compliance while claiming to educate, then the policy contradicts the mission.“

This suggests that if you really care about a subject, or approach, or principle, then you can’t rely on institutional policies to do all the work for you. We’re going to have to make the practices we care about sustainable.

Anyway, here is a screen recording of the talk in my delightful monotone:

2 Comments

  • Alan Levine

    I will always show up to read/listen to you spin metaphors, and the approach of using multiple ones makes it more richer to think about. I had wondered a bit why center on AI but of course thats likely what audience wants, as I can see the metaphors fitting more broadly for tech that includes, but to not limited to AI.

    The story of introduced species with bad consequences goes far. That the rabbits in Australia were the act of one dude says a lot, but am remembering as well in the southwest US the introduction of Tamirisk as a decoratoive plant has had drastic implications for choking out native plants and rivers in that arid region. Or the cases where one species is introduced to take care of a problem that becomes a different problem, so yet a different species is intriduced as a fix, and, well there the story goes.

    The rabbit fence in Australia is well known, but in a recently 99% invisible I learned about one I had not heard of, the dingo fence that is the longest continguous one anywhere, and it changed the ecosystem — https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/660-the-longest-fence-in-the-world/

    I find rewilding the most interesting one, as often it is change made by *not* doing something. When I. hear people talk about “rewilding the internet” it seems like something done as a fix or a tool, when really, as I have been doing on our land, much fo rewilding is just letting stuff go. Look, there’s a post! https://cogdogblog.com/2025/11/rewilding-landscapes/

    Always happy to see a new post here even though you are now a man of leisure and craft (jealous here of course)

    • mweller

      Hi Alan! Nice post. That’s an interesting point – rewilding can be letting go as you note, but sometimes it also has to be intentional (as in the reintroduction of wolves). As a metaphor then it is interesting to think when do we need to be deliberate and when just “get out of the way”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php