AI,  edtech

Slanty ed tech

Some of you may remember the Slanty toilet seat that came out in 2019. It was a toilet seat that sloped downwards at a 13 degree angle. The idea was that it would be uncomfortable to sit on and reduce long toilet breaks in companies, and thus, improve efficiency.

I’ve been thinking about the Slanty recently (just to clarify, I don’t spend a lot of time thinking about toilet seats, I’m not the US Secretary of Health or anything). The company is still in operation, although now they have decreased the focus of efficiency and increased the supposed health benefits.

So, why have I been thinking about this egregious example of late capitalism? Coz AI, obviously! There are a number of parallels I think (and maybe with other ed tech offerings more broadly). First of all, nobody, absolutely nobody, asked for this. People weren’t sitting around going “you know what bothers me the most? Toilet seat angles.” It was invented solely to make a buck, through, ahem, disrupting a previous practice. See also Blockchain.

Secondly, the pitch was based around efficiency. It’s always efficiency. I would suggest that organisations installing the Slanty probably don’t see any great upturn in efficiency – employees will be taking acts of petty revenge in lieu of their loo breaks. Of course, the great claim for AI is that it improves efficiency, but it doesn’t really – we simply create new tasks (such as combatting the use of AI in assessment, or journal articles). Improved efficiency is an easy, and lazy sell. Who doesn’t want to improve efficiency right? Nobody is pro-inefficiency. But any improvements in this rather mercurial measure should be side benefits to something you really want to do. I’d go as far as saying that any tech that proclaims improved efficiency as its main selling point is useless. It needs to do more.

Thirdly, it is anti-human, anti-joy. I don’t mean to romanticise the humble loo break, but it’s often the moment of quiet in a busy day (ask any parent). So it takes a special sort of human to think “hmm, let’s take that away from people.” Removing the fun or human parts of your job is also a common aspect of AI. Do you enjoy talking to people, or communicating with other humans online? Let’s get AI to do that. I do accept that people have fun with AI also.

Lastly, it gets pitched as being good for you. Hence the health message. Green-washing, Open-washing, Health-washing, Wellness-washing. It’s always sold as good for you, the individual. And purely by chance, it will benefit these companies as well. The Slanty is obviously aimed at improvements for the organisation over the individual, but a story needs to be told to sell it to the workforce. Ed tech and AI are not as clearly one-sided as this, and they can have benefits for staff and students. But if any of the ‘washing’ angles get promoted heavily that is often a sign that the equation is heavily balanced away from the individual.

Obviously a lot of ed tech is more complicated and thus these factors are not as easily identified. But having a simple example can be a useful tool. Asking yourself the question “Is this basically a slanted toilet seat we’re being sold here?” is not a bad approach.

Can we all just recognise how I made it through that post without making any poo-related jokes?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php