Remember (Professional) Ethics
Timothy Snyder’s 2017 book On Tyranny: Twenty Lessons from the Twentieth Century has been getting a lot of renewed interest over the past 18 months. I can’t imagine why. The often quoted rule is his first, Do Not Obey In Advance, but I was contemplating one of the others this week, in relation to, of all things, British Ice Hockey, and from there more generally. His Rule no 5 is:
Remember professional ethics. When political leaders set a negative example, professional commitments to just practice become important. It is hard to subvert a rule-of-law state without lawyers, or to hold show trials without judges. Authoritarians need obedient civil servants, and concentration camp directors seek businessmen interested in cheap labor.
A consequence of this is that it becomes much harder to undo damage once professions have compromised their ethics. Had judges, journalists and Congress stuck to their professional ethics earlier, then Trump would not be in power now. But once he is, then it becomes much more difficult to draw a line, since the power shifts, those institutions are deliberately undermined and you’ve demonstrated that you will buckle.
So, what’s that got to do with British Ice Hockey? There are only ten teams in the UK elite league (EIHL) and some of the smaller ones struggle to survive. Amongst these is Fife, the oldest club in the UK. They are usually at the bottom of the league and had a woeful season last year. New owners came in and this year they signed ex-NHL player Milan Lucic. Great news you might think, Lucic is a genuine star, if rather old now. But he also comes with an alleged history of domestic abuse. The reason he signed for the worst club in one of the lowest leagues in Europe is probably not a love of shortbread, but one might hazard rather because no-one else would have him. It was a controversial signing, causing their COO to quit as he objected to it.
But the Flyers thought they could tough out the negative criticism, and to be fair, the Lucic led team looked a vast improvement on last year. They also signed another ex-NHL player (and Trump supporter), David Booth. Last weekend was the Pride weekend in the EIHL, which has become a very well supported event, with each team wearing pride jerseys and donating to local LGBT charities. In the UK hockey is a niche sport and very inclusive. However, Booth reportedly refused to wear the jersey, and because all players have to wear the same jersey, Fife only wore their Pride jerseys in warm-up. This happened on the night despite promoting it as their pride night. They have responded that they were “respecting players beliefs”. When you consider that the aim of Pride night is to say “you are welcome here” one can only assume those beliefs are “you are not welcome here.”
And this is where those ethics come in. There has been considerable backlash to this. In a seemingly script-written Karma is a bitch outcome, Booth didn’t warm up because this would entail wearing the jersey, and then promptly got injured in the first period. He may now well be out for the rest of the season.
You can see Snyder’s rule playing out in real time here. Having compromised themselves in signing Lucic, the club demonstrated that they would abandon ethics for the right player. Booth senses this and pushes his agenda. The club is then embarrassed and undermined. I have heard that the other clubs in the league go some way to supporting Fife, because they want a league with ten teams. However, having worked very hard over the past decade to demonstrate that the sport is very inclusive, Fife are now undermining this single-handedly. The other clubs would not be best pleased I would guess. And losing their goodwill is a risky thing to do if you’re Fife, as is alienating half of your rather small fanbase. Had they stuck to their principles earlier, this mess would not have arisen. And for a player they may not even ice again.
All this sounds rather esoteric, but it’s a neat example of the principle I think. And there is a lesson for universities here. In the US we have seen many of them bend the knee to Trump, and we can imagine similar happening in the UK if Reform came to power. The lesson here is that as soon as you compromise your ethics, such as allowing Government to dictate what subjects you teach, then it will unravel quickly, and soon you’re stuck with the educational equivalent of an injured player who’ve you’ve allowed to undermine the coach, and devalued the other players. It’s a much more difficult road back from there than if you had just stood your ground to start with.
